| 1978-79 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Shep Messing | New York Arrows | GK | | Kai Haaskivi | Houston Summit | F | | Steve Zungul | New York Arrows | F | | Doug Wark | Cincinnati Kids | M | | Fred Grgurev | Philadelphia Fever | D | | Ian Anderson | Houston Summit | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Paul Hammond | Houston Summit | GK | | Stewart Jump | Houston Summit | F | | Jim Pollihan | New York Arrows | D | | Joe Fink | Philadelphia Fever | M | | Ty Keough | Cincinnati Kids | D | | Alan Hamlyn | Cleveland Force | D | | Tommy Mulroy | Pittsburgh Spirit | D |
|
| 1979-80 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Shep Messing | New York Arrows | GK | | Steve Zungul | New York Arrows | F | | Branko Segota | New York Arrows | F | | Kai Haaskivi | Houston Summit | M | | Ian Anderson | Houston Summit | D | | Flemming Lund | Detroit Lightning | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Alan Mayer | Pittsburgh Spirit | GK | | Fred Grgurev | Philadelphia Fever | F | | Steve Buttle | Pittsburgh Spirit | F | | Juli Veee | New York Arrows | F | | Clive Charles | Pittsburgh Spirit | D | | Steve Pecher | St. Louis Steamers | D | | Dave D'Errico | New York Arrows | D | | All-NASL 1st Team |
|
| | N/A |
|
|
|
| 1980-81 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Shep Messing | New York Arrows | GK | | Steve Zungul | New York Arrows | F | | Branko Segota | New York Arrows | F | | Tony Glavin | St. Louis Steamers | M | | Dave D'Errico | New York Arrows | D | | Steve Pecher | St. Louis Steamers | D | | Ian Anderson | Cleveland Force | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Richard But | Hartford Hellions | GK | | Paul Kitson | Chicago Horizon | F | | Charlie Cordas | Buffalo Stallions | F | | Vic Davidson | Phoenix Inferno | M | | Doc Lawson | Philadelphia Fever | D | | Jim Pollihan | Baltimore Blast | D | | All-NASL Eastern |
|
| | Tino Lettieri | Minnesota Kicks | GK | | Karl-Heinz Granitza | Chicago Sting |
| | Pato Margetic | Chicago Sting |
| | Keith Furphy | Atlanta Chiefs |
| | Bjorn Nordqvist | Minnesota Kicks |
| | Steve Wegerle | Tampa Bay Rowdies |
| | All-NASL Northern |
|
| | Bruce Grobbelaar | Vancouver Whitecaps | GK | | Carl Valentine | Vancouver Whitecaps |
| | Kai Haaskivi | Edmonton Drillers |
| | Rob Prentice | Toronto Blizzard |
| | Juan Carlos Molina | Calgary Boomers |
| | Drew Ferguson | Edmonton Drillers |
| | Gerry Gray | Vancouver Whitecaps |
| | All-NASL Western |
|
| | Mike Hewitt | San Jose Earthquakes | GK | | Juli Veee | San Diego Sockers |
| | Alan Hudson | Seattle Sounders |
| | Mihalj Keri | Los Angeles Aztecs |
| | George Best | San Jose Earthquakes |
| | Chris Dangerfield | Los Angeles Aztecs |
| | Stuart Lee | Portland Timbers |
|
|
1981-82
| | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Slobo Ilijevski | St. Louis Steamers | GK | | Steve Zungul | New York Arrows | F | | Stan Terlecki | Pittsburgh Spirit | F | | Stan Stamenkovic | Memphis Americans | F | | Val Tuksa | New York Arrows | D | | Helmut Dudek | Memphis Americans | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Mike Dowler | Wichita Wings | GK | | Steve David | Phoenix Inferno | F | | Joey Fink | Baltimore Blast | F | | Tony Glavin | St. Louis Steamers | M | | Ian Anderson | New Jersey Rockets | D | | Kevin Kewley | Wichita Wings | D | | All-NASL Pacific Conference 1st Team |
|
| | Volkmar Gross | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Jan Goossens | Edmonton Drillers | F | | Kai Haaskivi | Edmonton Drillers | F | | Juli Veee | San Diego Sockers | F | | Alan Hudson | Seattle Sounders | D | | Martin Donnelly | San Diego Sockers | D | | All-NASL Pacific Conference 2nd Team |
|
| | John Baretta | Edmonton Drillers | GK | | Dale Mitchell | Portland Timbers | F | | Carl Valentine | Vancouver Whitecaps | F | | Jean Willrich | San Diego Sockers | F | | Bernie James | Edmonton Drillers | D | | Gert Wieczorkowski | San Diego Sockers | D | | All-NASL Atlantic Conference 1st Team |
|
| | Jurgen Stars | Tampa Bay Rowdies | GK | | Tatu | Tampa Bay Rowdies | F | | Karl-Heinz Granitza | Chicago Sting | F | | Gordon Hill | Montreal Manic | F | | Barry Wallace | Tulsa Roughnecks | D | | Mike Connell | Tampa Bay Rowdies | D | | All-NASL Atlantic Conference 2nd Team |
|
| | Blagoje Tamindzic | Toronto Blizzard | GK | | Pato Margetic | Chicago Sting | F | | Laurie Abrahams | Tulsa Roughnecks | F | | Ingo Peter | Chicago Sting | F | | Derek Spalding | Chicago Sting | D | | John Gorman | Tampa Bay Rowdies | D |
|
| 1982-83 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Alan Mayer | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Steve Zungul | Golden Bay Earthquakes | F | | Stan Stamenkovic | Memphis Americans | F | | Juli Veee | San Diego Sockers | F | | Val Tuksa | New York Arrows | D | | Heinz Wirtz | Baltimore Blast | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Keith Van Eron | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Stan Terlecki | Pittsburgh Spirit | F | | Kai Haaskivi | Cleveland Force | F | | Jorgen Kristensen | Wichita Wings | M | | Greg Makowski | Kansas City Comets | D | | Kim Roentved | Wichita Wings | D |
|
| 1983-84 | All-MISL 1st Team
|
|
| | Slobo Ilijevski | St. Louis Steamers | GK | | Stan Stamenkovic | Baltimore Blast | F | | Andy Chapman | Wichita Wings | F | | Kai Haaskivi | Cleveland Force | M | | Sam Bick | St. Louis Steamers | D | | Kim Roentved | Wichita Wings | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Mike Dowler | Wichita Wings | GK | | Craig Allen | Cleveland Force | F | | Gordon Hill | Kansas City Comets | F | | Mark Liveric | New York Arrows | F | | Tony Bellinger | St. Louis Steamers | D | | Greg Makowski | Kansas City Comets | D | | All-NASL 1st Team |
|
| | Victor Nogueira | Chicago Sting | GK | | Steve Zungul | Golden Bay Earthquakes | F | | Karl-Heinz Granitza | Chicago Sting | F | | Kaz Deyna | San Diego Sockers | M | | Fernando Clavijo | Golden Bay Earthquakes | D | | Gert Wieczorkowski | San Diego Sockers | D | | All-NASL 2nd Team |
|
| | David Brcic | New York Cosmos | GK | | Carl Valentine | Vancouver Whitecaps | F | | Pato Margetic | Chicago Sting | F | | Stan Terlecki | New York Cosmos | F | | Juli Veee | San Diego Sockers | M | | Dan Canter | New York Cosmos | D | | Martin Donnelly | San Diego Sockers | D |
|
| 1984-85 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Scott Manning | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Steve Zungul | San Diego Sockers | F | | Karl-Heinz Granitza | Chicago Sting | F | | Branko Segota | San Diego Sockers | F | | Kevin Crow | San Diego Sockers | D | | Mike Stankovic | Baltimore Blast | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Slobo Ilijevski | St. Louis Steamers | GK | | Stan Stamenkovic | Baltimore Blast | F | | Tatu | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Jean Willrich | San Diego Sockers | M | | Kim Roentved | Wichita Wings | D | | Jorge Espinoza | Las Vegas Americans | D | | All-AISA 1st Team |
|
| | Rick Schweizer | Louisville Thunder | GK | | Lesh Shkreli | Columbus Capitals | F | | Kia Zolgharnain | Canton Invaders | F | | Pete Knezic | Milwaukee Wave | M | | Oscar Pisano | Canton Invaders | D | | Tom Alioto | Milwaukee Wave | D | | All-AISA 2nd Team |
|
| | Mike Barbarick | Canton Invaders | GK | | Art Kramer | Canton Invaders | F | | Jim Gabarra | Louisville Thunder | F | | Neil Ridgway | Kalamazoo Kangaroos | M | | Mike Noonan | Louisville Thunder | D | | Keith Tozer | Louisville Thunder | D |
|
| 1985-86 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | David Brcic | Pittsburgh Spirit | GK | | Steve Zungul | Tacoma Stars | F | | Erik Rasmussen | Wichita Wings | F | | Branko Segota | San Diego Sockers | F | | Kevin Crow | San Diego Sockers | D | | Mike Stankovic | Baltimore Blast | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Jim Gorsek | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Craig Allen | Cleveland Force | F | | Tatu | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Chico Borja | Wichita Wings | M | | Bruce Savage | Baltimore Blast | D | | Bernie James | Cleveland Force | D | | All-AISA 1st Team |
|
| | Victor Petroni | Kalamazoo Kangaroos | GK | | Kia Zolgharnain | Canton Invaders | F | | Zoran Savic | Louisville Thunder | F | | Don Tobin | Canton Invaders | M | | Oscar Pisano | Canton Invaders | D | | Tim Tyma | Canton Invaders | D | | All-AISA 2nd Team |
|
| | Jamie Swanner | Canton Invaders | GK | | Chris Hellenkamp | Louisville Thunder | F | | Ross Ongaro | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Pete Knezic | Milwaukee Wave | M | | Martin Rincon | Chicago Shoccers | D | | Saeed Bakhtiari | Louisville Thunder | D |
|
| 1986-87 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Krys Sobieski | Dallas Sidekicks | GK | | Tatu | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Steve Zungul | Tacoma Stars | F | | Kai Haaskivi | Cleveland Force | M | | Bruce Savage | Baltimore Blast | D | | Kevin Crow | San Diego Sockers | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Tino Lettieri | Minnesota Strikers | GK | | Jan Goossens | Kansas City Comets | F | | Preki | Tacoma Stars | F | | Branko Segota | San Diego Sockers | F | | Bernie James | Cleveland Force | D | | Fernando Clavijo | San Diego Sockers | D | | All-AISA 1st Team |
|
| | Jamie Swanner | Canton Invaders | GK | | Zoran Savic | Louisville Thunder | F | | Rudy Pikuzinski | Canton Invaders | F | | Chris Hellenkamp | Louisville Thunder | M | | Gregg Willen | Memphis Storm | D | | Tim Tyma | Canton Invaders | D | | All-AISA 2nd Team |
|
| | Arnie Mausser | Tampa Bay Rowdies | GK | | Salvador Valencia | Chicago Shoccers | F | | Carlos Salguero | Toledo Pride | F | | Elvis Comrie | Chicago Shoccers | M | | Martin Rincon | Chicago Shoccers | D | | Tomo Condric | Canton Invaders | D |
|
| 1987-88 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Zoltan Toth | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Preki | Tacoma Stars | F | | Erik Rasmussen | Wichita Wings | F | | Branko Segota | San Diego Sockers | F | | Fernando Clavijo | San Diego Sockers | D | | Kevin Crow | San Diego Sockers | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Krys Sobieski | Dallas Sidekicks | GK | | Jan Goossens | Kansas City Comets | F | | Hector Marinaro | Minnesota Strikers | F | | Chico Borja | Los Angeles Lazers | M | | Bruce Savage | Baltimore Blast | D | | Chris Whyte | Los Angeles Lazers | D | | All-AISA 1st Team |
|
| | Manny Sanchez | Memphis Storm | GK | | Ted Hantak | Memphis Storm | F | | Rudy Pikuzinski | Canton Invaders | F | | Chris Hellenkamp | Ft. Wayne Flames | M | | Vincent Beck | Memphis Storm | D | | Tim Tyma | Milwaukee Wave | D |
|
| 1988-89 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Victor Nogueira | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Preki | Tacoma Stars | F | | Dale Mitchell | Kansas City Comets | F | | Chico Borja | Wichita Wings | M | | Kevin Crow | San Diego Sockers | D | | Bruce Savage | Baltimore Blast | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Scott Manning | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Hector Marinaro | Los Angeles Lazers | F | | Erik Rasmussen | Wichita Wings | F | | Branko Segota | San Diego Sockers | F | | Tim Wittman | Baltimore Blast | D | | Chico Moreira | Wichita Wings | D | | All-AISA 1st Team |
|
| | Jamie Swanner | Canton Invaders | GK | | Karl-Heinz Granitza | Chicago Power | F | | Rudy Pikuzinski | Canton Invaders | F | | Charlie Greene | Hershey Impact | M | | Tim Tyma | Milwaukee Wave | D | | Bret Hall | Chicago Power | D | | All-AISA 2nd Team |
|
| | Tony Pierce | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Art Kramer | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Rod Castro | Memphis Storm | F | | Franklin McIntosh | Hershey Impact | M | | Saeed Bakhtiari | Milwaukee Wave | D | | Randy Prescott | Ft. Wayne Flames | D |
|
| 1989-90 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Scott Manning | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Tatu | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Jan Goossens | Kansas City Comets | F | | Preki | Tacoma Stars | F | | Wes McLeod | Dallas Sidekicks | D | | Bruce Savage | Baltimore Blast | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Joe Papaleo | Dallas Sidekicks | GK | | Dale Mitchell | Kansas City Comets | F | | Michael King | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Tim Wittman | Baltimore Blast | M | | Kevin Crow | San Diego Sockers | D | | Mike Powers | Dallas Sidekicks | D | | All-AISA 1st Team |
|
| | Jamie Swanner | Canton Invaders | GK | | Peter Hattrup | Atlanta Attack | F | | Drago Dumbovic | Hershey Impact | F | | Rudy Pikuzinski | Canton Invaders | F | | Bret Hall | Chicago Power | D | | Tim Tyma | Milwaukee Wave | D | | All-AISA 2nd Team |
|
| | Carlos Pena | Dayton Dynamo | GK | | Tony Bono | Dayton Dynamo | F | | Dan O'Keefe | Indiana Kick | F | | Marcelo Carrera | Canton Invaders | F | | Bob DiNunzio | Canton Invaders | D | | Oscar Pisano | Canton Invaders | D |
|
| 1990-91 | | All-MSL 1st Team |
|
| | Victor Nogueira | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Tatu | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Zoran Karic | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Preki | St. Louis Storm | F | | Kevin Crow | San Diego Sockers | D | | Fernando Clavijo | St. Louis Storm | D | | All-MSL 2nd Team |
|
| | Cris Vaccaro | Tacoma Stars | GK | | Jan Goossens | Kansas City Comets | F | | Thompson Usiyan | St. Louis Storm | F | | Brian Quinn | San Diego Sockers | M | | Bernie James | Cleveland Crunch | D | | Ralph Black | Tacoma Stars | D | | All-NPSL 1st Team |
|
| | Jamie Swanner | Canton Invaders | GK | | Andy Chapman | Detroit Rockers | F | | Gino DiFlorio | Canton Invaders | F | | Pato Margetic | Chicago Power | M | | Denzil Antonio | Canton Invaders | D | | Arturo Velazco | Milwaukee Wave | D | | All-NPSL 2nd Team |
|
| | Tony Pierce | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Mirko Castillo | Chicago Power | F | | Zoran Savic | Atlanta Attack | F | | Tony Bono | Dayton Dynamo | M | | Michael Richardson | Chicago Power | D | | Bret Hall | Chicago Power | D |
|
| 1991-92 | | All-MSL 1st Team |
|
| | Victor Nogueira | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Zoran Karic | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Preki | St. Louis Ambush | F | | Tatu | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Kevin Crow | San Diego Sockers | D | | Iain Fraser | Baltimore Blast | D | | All-MSL 2nd Team |
|
| | Joe Papaleo | Dallas Sidekicks | GK | | David Doyle | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Dale Ervine | Wichita Wings | F | | Chico Borja | Wichita Wngs | M | | George Fernandez | Cleveland Crunch | D | | Ben Collins | San Diego Sockers | D | | All-MSL 3rd Team |
|
| | Cris Vaccaro | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Hector Marinaro | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Paul Wright | San Diego Sockers | F/M | | Branko Segota | St. Louis Storm | M | | Danny Pena | Wichita Wings | D | | Wes McLeod | Dallas Sidekicks | D | | All-NPSL 1st Team |
|
| | Jamie Swanner | Canton Invaders | GK | | Brian Haynes | Kansas City Attack | F | | Dan O'Keefe | Detroit Rockers | F | | Michael Richardson | Chicago Power | M | | Matt Knowles | Illinois Thunder | D | | Bret Hall | Chicago Power | D | | All-NPSL 2nd Team |
|
| | Russ Prince | Chicago Power | GK | | Pato Margetic | Chicago Power | F | | Eloy Salgado | Tulsa Ambush | F | | Franklin McIntosh | Harrisburg Heat | M | | Denzil Antonio | Canton Invaders | D | | Gino Schiraldi | Kansas City Comets | D |
|
| 1992-93 | | All-NPSL 1st Team |
|
| | Cris Vaccaro | Baltimore Spirit | GK | | Hector Marinaro | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Zoran Karic | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Rudy Pikuzinski | Buffalo Blizzard | F | | Kim Roentved | Wichita Wings | D | | Sean Bowers | Detroit Rockers | D | | All-NPSL 2nd Team |
|
| | Kris Peat | Wichita Wings | GK | | Pato Margetic | Chicago Power | F | | Jon Parry | Kansas City Attack | F | | Goran Hunjak | Baltimore Spirit | F | | Terry Woodberry | Wichita Wings | D | | George Fernandez | Cleveland Crunch | D | | All-NPSL 3rd Team |
|
| | Jamie Swanner | Buffalo Blizzard | GK | | Franklin McIntosh | Harrisburg Heat | F | | Randy Pikuzinski | Buffalo Blizzard | F | | Gino DiFlorio | Canton Invaders | F | | Daryl Doran | St. Louis Ambush | D | | Denzil Antonio | Canton Invaders | D | | Doug Neely | Baltimore Spirit | D |
|
| 1993 | | All-CISL 1st Team |
|
| | Joe Papaleo | Dallas Sidekicks | GK | | Tatu | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | David Doyle | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Kevin Smith | Monterrey La Raza | M | | David Banks | San Diego Sockers | D | | Sean Bowers | Sacramento Knights | D | | All-CISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Bryan Finnerty | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Zizinho | Monterrey La Raza | F | | Wes Wade | Arizona Sandsharks | F | | Kevin Koetters | San Diego Sockers | M | | Mike Powers | Dallas Sidekicks | D | | Neil Megson | Portland Pride | D |
|
| 1993-94 | | All-NPSL 1st Team |
|
| | Victor Nogueira | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Hector Marinaro | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Zoran Karic | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Andy Chapman | Detroit Rockers | F | | Sean Bowers | Detroit Rockers | D | | Terry Woodberry | Wichita Wings | D | | All-NPSL 2nd Team |
|
| | Cris Vaccaro | Baltimore Spirit | GK | | Paul Wright | Baltimore Spirit | F | | David Doyle | St. Louis Ambush | F | | Pato Margetic | Chicago Power | M | | George Fernandez | Cleveland Crunch | D | | Daryl Doran | St. Louis Ambush | D | | All-NPSL 3rd Team |
|
| | Brian Finnerty | Detroit Rockers | GK | | Gino DiFlorio | Canton Invaders | F | | Kevin Koetters | Kansas City Attack | M | | Franklin McIntosh | Harrisburg Heat | M | | Kim Roentved | Wichita Wings | D | | Doug Neely | Baltimore Spirit | D |
|
| 1994 | | All-CISL 1st Team |
|
| | Joe Papaleo | Dallas Sidekicks | GK | | Tatu | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | David Doyle | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Goran Hunjak | Washington Warthogs | M | | Terry Woodberry | Arizona Sandsharks | D | | Ralph Black | Anaheim Splash | D | | All-CISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Mike Dowler | Sacramento Knights | GK | | Zizinho | Monterrey La Raza | F | | Drago Dumbovic | Detroit Neon | F | | Doug Neely | Anaheim Splash | M | | Rene Ortiz | San Diego Sockers | D | | Eric Dade | Dallas Sidekicks | D |
|
| 1994-95 | | All-NPSL 1st Team |
|
| | Jamie Swanner | St. Louis Ambush | GK | | Hector Marinaro | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Zoran Karic | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Mark Moser | St. Louis Ambush | F | | Sean Bowers | Detroit Rockers | D | | Iain Fraser | Kansas City Attack | D | | All-NPSL 2nd Team |
|
| | Victor Nogueira | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Goran Hunjak | Kansas City Attack | F | | Dennis Brose | Dayton Dynamo | F | | Paul Dougherty | Buffalo Blizzard | F | | Kim Roentved | Wichita Wings | D | | Kevin Hundelt | St. Louis Ambush | D | | All-NPSL 3rd Team |
|
| | Warren Westcoat | Kansas City Attack | GK | | Wes Wade | Kansas City Attack | F | | Pato Margetic | Detroit Rockers | F | | Kevin Sloan | Baltimore Spirit | F | | Matt Knowles | Milwaukee Wave | D | | Daryl Doran | St. Louis Ambush | D |
|
| 1995 | | All-CISL 1st Team |
|
| | Mike Dowler | Sacramento Knights | GK | | Tatu | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Zizinho | Monterrey La Raza | F | | Preki | San Jose Grizzlies | M/F | | Danny Pena | Sacramento Knights | D | | Genoni Martinez | Monterrey La Raza | D | | All-CISL 2nd Team |
|
| | PJ Johns | Pittsburgh Stingers | GK | | Jeff Betts | Portland Pride | F | | Jon Parry | Sacramento Knights | F | | Mark Chung | San Diego Sockers | M | | Iain Fraser | Sacramento Knights | M/D | | Sean Bowers | Anaheim Splash | D |
|
| 1995-96 | | All-NPSL 1st Team |
|
| | Victor Nogueira | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Hector Marinaro | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Zoran Karic | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Joe Reiniger | St. Louis Ambush | F | | Matt Knowles | Milwaukee Wave | D | | Daryl Doran | St. Louis Ambush | D | | All-NPSL 2nd Team |
|
| | Scoop Stanisic | Harrisburg Heat | GK | | Marcelo Carrera | Buffalo Blizzard | F | | Danny Kelly | Harrisburg Heat | M | | Kevin Koetters | Kansas City Attack | M | | Kevin Hundelt | St. Louis Ambush | D | | Mike Stankovic | Baltimore Spirit | D | | All-NPSL 3rd Team |
|
| | Brett Phillips | Kansas City Attack | GK | | Michael King | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Franklin McIntosh | Baltimore Spirit | M | | Shawn Medved | Cincinnati Silverbacks | M | | Kim Roentved | Wichita Wings | D | | Jim Schwab | Kansas City Attack | D |
|
| 1996 | | All-CISL 1st Team |
|
| | Brett Phillips | Washington Warthogs | GK | | Tatu | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | David Doyle | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Paul Dougherty | Houston Hotshots | M | | Genoni Martinez | Monterrey La Raza | D | | Danny Pena | Sacramento Knights | D | | All-CISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Juan De La O | Seattle SeaDogs | GK | | Marco Lopez | Monterrey La Raza | F | | Dale Ervine | Anaheim Splash | F | | Mariano Bollella | Indianapolis Twisters | M | | David Banks | San Diego Sockers | D | | Troy Snyder | Washington Warthogs | D |
|
| 1996-97 | | All-NPSL 1st Team |
|
| | Victor Nogueira | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Hector Marinaro | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Zoran Karic | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Dennis Brose | Detroit Rockers | F | | Wes Wade | Kansas City Attack | D | | Daryl Doran | St. Louis Ambush | D | | All-NPSL 2nd Team |
|
| | Carlos Pena | Cincinnati Silverbacks | GK | | Michael King | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Joe Reiniger | St. Louis Ambush | F | | Mark Moser | St. Louis Ambush | F | | Ricky Mobley | Milwaukee Wave | D | | Randy Prescott | Detroit Rockers | D | | All-NPSL 3rd Team |
|
| | Scott Hileman | Edmonton Drillers | GK | | Goran Hunjak | Kansas City Attack | F | | Bo Vuckovic | Baltimore Spirit | F | | Franklin McIntosh | Cincinnati Silverbacks | M | | Kim Roentved | Wichita Wings | D | | Genoni Martinez | Wichita Wings | D |
|
| 1997 | | All-CISL 1st Team |
|
| | Juan De La O | Seattle SeaDogs | GK | | John Olu-Molomo | Seattle SeaDogs | F | | Tatu | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Paul Dougherty | Houston Hotshots | M | | Genoni Martinez | Monterrey La Raza | D | | David Banks | Houston Hotshots | D | | All-CISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Dan Madsen | Sacramento Knights | GK | | Jean Harbor | Seattle SeaDogs | F | | Ziad Allan | Houston Hotshots | F | | Dick McCormick | Seattle SeaDogs | M | | Iain Fraser | Sacramento Knights | D | | Doug Neely | Anaheim Splash | D |
|
| 1997-98 | | All-NPSL 1st Team |
|
| | Victor Nogueira | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Hector Marinaro | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Zoran Karic | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Joe Reiniger | St. Louis Ambush | F | | Matt Knowles | Philadelphia Kixx | D | | Daryl Doran | St. Louis Ambush | D | | All-NPSL 2nd Team |
|
| | Scott Hileman | Edmonton Drillers | GK | | Gino DiFlorio | Canton Invaders | F | | Michael King | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Erik Rasmussen | Wichita Wings | F | | Omid Namazi | Philadelphia Kixx | D | | Wes Wade | Kansas City Attack | D | | All-NPSL 3rd Team |
|
| | Pete Pappas | Philadelphia Kixx | GK | | Rudy Pikuzinski | Buffalo Blizzard | F | | Kevin Sloan | Philadelphia Kixx | F | | Bo Vuckovic | Baltimore Spirit | F | | Todd Rattee | Edmonton Drillers | D | | Randy Prescott | Detroit Rockers | D | | Richard Chinapoo | Harrisburg Heat | D |
|
| 1998 | | All-PSA 1st Team |
|
| | Dan Madsen | Sacramento Knights | GK | | David Doyle | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Tatu | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Jeff Betts | Portland Pythons | M | | Iain Fraser | Sacramento Knights | D | | Rusty Troy | Dallas Sidekicks | D | | All-PSA 2nd Team |
|
| | Shawn Ray | Dallas Sidekicks | GK | | Jeff Alcala | Sacramento Knights | F | | Nick Stavrou | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Danny Barber | Sacramento Knights | M | | Bill Crook | Portland Pythons | D | | Jason Vanacour | Arizona Thunder | D |
|
| 1998-99 | | All-NPSL 1st Team |
|
| | Victor Nogueira | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Hector Marinaro | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Erik Rasmussen | Wichita Wings | F | | Doug Miller | Buffalo Blizzard | F | | Kevin Hundelt | St. Louis Ambush | D | | Matt Knowles | Philadelphia Kixx | D | | All-NPSL 2nd Team |
|
| | Pat Onstad | Edmonton Drillers | GK | | Gino DiFlorio | Harrisburg Heat | F | | Zoran Karic | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Joe Reiniger | St. Louis Ambush | F | | Todd Rattee | Edmonton Drillers | D | | Genoni Martinez | Wichita Wings | D | | All-NPSL 3rd Team |
|
| | Paolo Ceccarelli | Montreal Impact | GK | | Mauro Biello | Montreal Impact | F | | Ken Snow | Philadelphia Kixx | F | | Michael King | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Droo Callahan | Detroit Rockers | D | | Glenn Carbonara | Milwaukee Wave | D |
|
| 1999 | | All-WISL 1st Team |
|
| | Brett Phillips | Portland Pythons | GK | | David Doyle | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Tatu | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Mariano Bollella | Monterrey La Raza | M | | Iain Fraser | Sacramento Knights | D | | Alejandro Cardenas | Monterrey La Raza | D | | All-WISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Raul Salas | Monterrey La Raza | GK | | Rick Soderman | Arizona Thunder | F | | Bernie Lilavois | Portland Pythons | F | | Beau Brown | Utah Freezz | M | | Randy Soderman | Arizona Thunder | D | | Rusty Troy | Dallas Sidekicks | D |
|
| 1999-2000 | | All-NPSL 1st Team |
|
| | Victor Nogueira | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Hector Marinaro | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Gino DiFlorio | Harrisburg Heat | F | | Jason Dunn | Wichita Wings | F | | James Dunn | Wichita Wings | D | | Michael Richardson | Milwaukee Wave | D | | All-NPSL 2nd Team |
|
| | Scott Hileman | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Clovis Simas | Kansas City Attack | F | | Nikola Vignjevic | Edmonton Drillers | F | | Braeden Cloutier | Wichita Wings | F | | Jeff Davis | Kansas City Attack | D | | Todd Rattee | Edmonton Drillers | D | | All-NPSL 3rd Team |
|
| | Peter Pappas | Philadelphia Kixx | GK | | Wes Wade | Kansas City Attack | F | | Joe Reiniger | St. Louis Ambush | F | | Denison Cabral | Baltimore Blast | F | | Droo Callahan | Detroit Rockers | D | | Oscar Draguicevich | Cleveland Crunch | D |
|
| 2000 | | All-WISL 1st Team |
|
| | Sagu | Dallas Sidekicks | GK | | Tatu | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | David Doyle | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Mariano Bollella | Monterrey La Raza | M | | Jason Vanacour | Arizona Thunder | D | | Kiley Couch | Houston Hotshots | D | | All-WISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Juan De La O | Arizona Thunder | GK | | Beau Brown | Utah Freezz | F | | Marco Lopez | Monterrey La Raza | F | | Nick Stavrou | Dallas Sidekicks | M | | Jeff Davis | St. Louis Steamers | D | | Genoni Martinez | Monterrey La Raza | D |
|
| 2000-01 | | All-NPSL 1st Team |
|
| | Victor Nogueira | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Hector Marinaro | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Gino DiFlorio | Harrisburg Heat | F | | David Bascome | Harrisburg Heat | F | | Omid Namazi | Philadelphia Kixx | D | | Glenn Carbonara | Milwaukee Wave | D | | All-NPSL 2nd Team |
|
| | Peter Pappas | Philadelphia Kixx | GK | | Joe Reiniger | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Dino Delevski | Wichita Wings | F | | Denison Cabral | Baltimore Blast | F | | Droo Callahan | Detroit Rockers | D | | Wes Wade | Kansas City Attack | D | | All-NPSL 3rd Team |
|
| | Doug Petras | Harrisburg Heat | GK | | Domenic Mobilio | Detroit Rockers | F | | Mauro Biello | Toronto Thunderhawks | F | | Bernie Lilavois | Harrisburg Heat | F | | John Ball | Cleveland Crunch | D | | Jason Dieter | Baltimore Blast | D |
|
| 2001 | | All-WISL 1st Team |
|
| | Sagu | Dallas Sidekicks | GK | | Carlos Farias | San Diego Sockers | F | | Ato Leone | Sacramento Knights | F | | Mariano Bollella | San Diego Sockers
| M | | Iain Fraser | Sacramento Knights | D | | Jeff Davis | St. Louis Steamers | D | | All-WISL 2nd Team |
|
| | DJ Horvath | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Justin Labrum | Utah Freezz | F | | David Doyle | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Beau Brown | Utah Freezz | M | | Daryl Doran | St. Louis Steamers | D | | Alejandro Cardenas | San Diego Sockers | D |
|
| 2001-02 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Victor Nogueira | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Hector Marinaro | Cleveland Crunch | F | | Dino Delevski | Kansas City Comets | F | | Joe Reiniger | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Sean Bowers | Baltimore Blast | D | | Pat Morris | Philadelphia Kixx | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Peter Pappas | Philadelphia Kixx | GK | | David Bascome | Harrisburg Heat | F | | Brian Loftin | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Denison Cabral | Baltimore Blast | F | | Nick Corneli | Harrisburg Heat | D | | Troy Dusosky | Milwaukee Wave | D |
|
| 2002-03 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Victor Nogueira | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Dino Delevski | Kansas City Comets | F | | Greg Howes | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Joe Reiniger | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Genoni Martinez | Harrisburg Heat | D | | Sean Bowers | Baltimore Blast | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Peter Pappas | Philadelphia Kixx | GK | | Todd Dusosky | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Carlos Farias | San Diego Sockers | F | | David Bascome | Harrisburg Heat | F | | Troy Dusosky | Milwaukee Wave | D | | Pat Morris | Philadelphia Kixx | D |
|
| 2003-04 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Peter Pappas | Philadelphia Kixx | GK | | Greg Howes | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Todd Dusosky | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Carlos Farias | Baltimore Blast | F | | Genoni Martinez | Monterrey Fury | D | | Pat Morris | Philadelphia Kixx | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Dan Green | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Dino Delevski | Kansas City Comets | F | | Denison Cabral | Baltimore Blast | F | | Don D'Ambra | Philadelphia Kixx | F | | Sean Bowers | Baltimore Blast | D | | Jeff Davis | Kansas City Comets | D |
|
| 2004-05 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Peter Pappas | Philadelphia Kixx | GK | | Greg Howes | Milwaukee Wave | F | | John Ball | Cleveland Force | F | | Don D'Ambra | Philadelphia Kixx | F | | Pat Morris | Philadelphia Kixx | D | | Genoni Martinez | Cleveland Force | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Nick Vorberg | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Dino Delevski | Kansas City Comets | F | | Giuliano Celenza | Baltimore Blast | F | | Carlos Farias | St. Louis Steamers | F | | Chris Morman | Milwaukee Wave | D | | Vlatko Andonovski | Kansas City Comets | D |
|
| 2005-06 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Brett Phillips | St. Louis Steamers | GK | | Greg Howes | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Adauto Neto | Baltimore Blast | F | | Giuliano Celenza | Baltimore Blast | F | | Genoni Martinez | St. Louis Steamers | D | | Pat Morris | Philadelphia Kixx | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Sagu | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Todd Dusosky | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Jamar Beasley | St. Louis Steamers | F | | Shaun David | St. Louis Steamers | F | | Carlos Farias | St. Louis Steamers | F | | Matt Schmidt | Milwaukee Wave | D | | Lazo Alavanjo | Chicago Storm | D | | Danny Kelly | Baltimore Blast | D |
|
| 2006-07 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Peter Pappas | Philadelphia Kixx | GK | | Jamar Beasley | Detroit Ignition | F | | Greg Howes | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Don D'Ambra | Philadelphia Kixx | F | | Genoni Martinez | Philadelphia Kixx | D | | Pat Morris | Philadelphia Kixx | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Sagu | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Sanaldo | Detroit Ignition | GK | | Mark Ughy | Chicago Storm | F | | Todd Dusosky | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Stephen Armstrong | Chicago Storm | F | | Jonathan Greenfield | Detroit Ignition | D | | Troy Dusosky | Milwaukee Wave | D |
|
| 2007-08 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Sagu | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Greg Howes | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Dino Delevski | Monterrey La Raza | F | | Dan Antoniuk | New Jersey Ironmen | F | | Genoni Martinez | Monterrey La Raza | D | | Droo Callahan | Detroit Ignition | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Danny Waltman | Detroit Ignition | GK | | Denison Cabral | Baltimore Blast | F | | Marcio Leite | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Jamar Beasley | Detroit Ignition | F | | PJ Wakefield | Baltimore Blast | D | | Pat Morris | Philadelphia Kixx | D |
|
| 2008-09 | | All-XSL 1st Team |
|
| | Danny Waltman | Detroit Ignition | GK | | Lucio Gonzaga | New Jersey Ironmen | M/F | | Adauto Neto | New Jersey Ironmen | M/F | | Marco Terminesi | Milwaukee Wave | M/F | | Troy Dusosky | Milwaukee Wave | D | | Josh Rife | Detroit Ignition | D | | All-NISL 1st Team |
|
| | Sagu | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Byron Alvarez | Monterrey La Raza | F | | Machel Millwood | Baltimore Blast | F | | Ricardinho | Philadelphia Kixx | M | | Pat Morris | Philadelphia Kixx | D | | Genoni Martinez | Monterrey La Raza | D | | All-NISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Sanaldo | Rockford Rampage | GK | | Hewerton Moreira | Philadelphia Kixx | F | | Bato Radoncic | Rockford Rampage | F | | Matt Stewart | Rockford Rampage | M | | PJ Wakefield | Baltimore Blast | D | | Tijani Ayegbusi | Rockford Rampage | D | | All-PASL 1st Team |
|
| | Craig Salvati | 1790 Cincinnati | GK | | Aaron Susi | Stockton Cougars | F | | Elvir Kafedzic | St. Louis Illusion | F | | Brian Farber | Stockton Cougars | M | | Justin McMillian | St. Louis Illusion | D | | Garrett Buck | 1790 Cincinnati | D | | All-PASL 2nd Team |
|
| | Bryan Klaus | Calgary United | GK | | Junior Garcia | Wenatchee Fire | F | | Majell Aterado | Stockton Cougars | M | | Shawn Rockey | 1790 Cincinnati | M | | Pedro Lupercio | Stockton Cougars | D | | Jeff Hughes | 1790 Cincinnati | D |
|
| 2009-10 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Nick Vorberg | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Adauto Neto | Philadelphia Kixx | F | | Machel Millwood | Baltimore Blast | F | | Carlos Farias | Monterrey La Raza | F | | Genoni Martinez | Monterrey La Raza | D | | Pat Morris | Philadelphia Kixx | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Sagu | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Lucio Gonzaga | Baltimore Blast | F | | Giuliano Oliviero | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Marco Terminesi | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Josh Rife | Milwaukee Wave | D | | Troy Dusosky | Milwaukee Wave | D | | All-PASL 1st Team |
|
| | Riley Swift | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Allen Eller | Ohio Vortex | F | | Safet Kovacevic | Louisville Lightning | F | | Jeff Hughes | 1790 Cincinnati Express | M | | Dan Antoniuk | San Diego Sockers | D | | Jeff Henderson | 1790 Cincinnati Express | D | | All-PASL 2nd Team |
|
| | Craig Salvati | 1790 Cincinnati Express | GK | | Kraig Chiles | San Diego Sockers | F | | Paul Wright | San Diego Sockers | M | | Brian Farber | California Cougars | M | | Nelson Santana | California Cougars | M | | Jonathan Kincheloe | Louisville Lightning | D | | Antonio Sutton | California Cougars | D |
|
| 2010-11 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Sagu | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Byron Alvarez | Missouri Comets | F | | Marco Terminesi | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Bato Radoncic | Chicago Riot | F | | Pat Morris | Baltimore Blast | D | | Leo Gibson | Missouri Comets | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Nick Vorberg | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Johnny Torres | Omaha Vipers | F | | Pat Healey | Baltimore Blast | F | | Jamar Beasley | Missouri Comets | F | | Josh Rife | Milwaukee Wave | D | | Mike Lookingland | Baltimore Blast | D | | All-PASL 1st Team |
|
| | Craig Salvati | Cincinnati Kings | GK | | Kraig Chiles | San Diego Sockers | F | | Jeff Hughes | Cincinnati Kings | F | | Eduardo Velez | Revolucion Tijuana | M | | Dan Antoniuk | San Diego Sockers | D | | Ze Roberto | San Diego Sockers | D | | All-PASL 2nd Team |
|
| | Riley Swift | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Greg Howes | Tacoma Stars | F | | Diego Rovira | San Diego Sockers | M | | Costea Decu | Detroit Waza Flo | M | | Antonio Sutton | California Cougars | D | | Jeff Henderson | Cincinnati Kings | D |
|
| 2011-12 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Sagu | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Mauricio Salles | Rochester Lancers | F | | Max Ferdinand | Baltimore Blast | M | | Geison Moura | Missouri Comets | M | | Mike Lookingland | Baltimore Blast | D | | Nelson Santana | Syracuse Silver Knights | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Danny Waltman | Missouri Comets | GK | | Byron Alvarez | Missouri Comets | F | | Machel Millwood | Baltimore Blast | F | | Marcio Leite | Milwaukee Wave | M | | Leo Gibson | Missouri Comets | D | | Joe Hammes | Milwaukee Wave | D | | All-PASL 1st Team |
|
| | Vito Lonigro | Detroit Waza Flo | GK | | Kraig Chiles | San Diego Sockers | F | | Brian Farber | San Diego Sockers | M | | Miki Djerisilo | Detroit Waza Flo | M | | Costea Decu | Detroit Waza Flo | D | | Adriano DeLima | Anaheim Bolts | D | | All-PASL 2nd Team |
|
| | Riley Swift | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Cesar Romero | Revolucion Tijuana | F | | Allen Eller | Cincnnati Kings | F | | Jorge Quiroz | Turlock Express | M | | Jesse Horta | Turlock Express | D | | Ze Roberto | San Diego Sockers | D |
|
| 2012-13 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | Nick Vorberg | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Mauricio Salles | Rochester Lancers | M/F | | Elmo Neto | Syracuse Silver Knights | M/F | | Doug Miller | Rochester Lancers | M/F | | Leo Gibson | Missouri Comets | D | | Mike Lookingland | Baltimore Blast | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Jeff Richey | Chicago Soul | GK | | Vahid Assadpour | Missouri Comets | M/F | | Carlos Farias | Chicago Soul | M/F | | Luan Oliveira | Milwaukee Wave | M/F | | Nelson Santana | Syracuse Silver Knights | D | | Pat Healey | Baltimore Blast | D | | All-PASL 1st Team |
|
| | Sagu | Dallas Sidekicks | GK | | Nestor Hernandez | Chicago Mustangs | F | | Kraig Chiles | San Diego Sockers | F | | Brian Farber | San Diego Sockers | M | | Costea Decu | Detroit Waza Flo | D | | Eric Guzman | Las Vegas Legends | D | | All-PASL 2nd Team |
|
| | Joey Kapinos | Detroit Waza Flo | GK | | Enrique Tovar | Las Vegas Legends | F | | Aaron Susi | San Diego Sockers | F | | Ivan Campos | Turlock Express | F | | Kiley Couch | Dallas Sidekicks | D | | Damian Garcia | Rio Grande Valley Flash | D |
|
| 2013-14 | | All-MISL 1st Team |
|
| | William Vanzela | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Kenardo Forbes | Syracuse Silver Knights | M/F | | Leo Gibson | Missouri Comets | M/F | | Marcio Leite | Milwaukee Wave | M/F | | Mike Lookingland | Baltimore Blast | D | | Nelson Santana | Syracuse Silver Knights | D | | All-MISL 2nd Team |
|
| | Marcel Feenstra | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Vahid Assadpour | Missouri Comets | M/F | | Ian Bennett | Milwaukee Wave | M/F | | Machel Millwood | Syracuse Silver Knights | M/F | | Brian Harris | Missouri Comets | D | | Bo Jelovac | Syracuse Silver Knights | D | | All-PASL 1st Team |
|
| | Juan Gamboa | Hidalgo La Fiera | GK | | Kraig Chiles | San Diego Sockers | F | | Efrain Martinez | Chicago Mustangs | F | | Enrique Tovar | Las Vegas Legends | M | | Alex Caceres | Las Vegas Legends | D | | Genoni Martinez | Monterrey Flash | D | | All-PASL 2nd Team |
|
| | Jesus Flores | Chicago Mustangs | GK | | Allen Eller | Cleveland Freeze | F | | Jamie Lovegrove | Dallas Sidekicks | M | | Miguel Vaca | Chicago Mustangs | M | | Costea Decu | Detroit Waza Flo | D | | Josh Grossman | Cleveland Freeze | D |
|
| 2014-15 | | All-MASL 1st Team |
|
| | William Vanzela | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Leo Gibson | Missouri Comets | F | | Kraig Chiles | San Diego Sockers | F | | Vahid Assadpour | Missouri Comets | M | | John Sosa | Missouri Comets | D | | Brian Harris | Missouri Comets | D | | All-MASL 2nd Team |
|
| | Danny Waltman | Missouri Comets | GK | | Gordy Gurson | Seattle Impact/St. Louis Ambush | F | | Mauricio Salles | Rochester Lancers | F | | Tiguinho Dias | Ontario Fury | M | | Eduardo Velez | San Diego Sockers | D | | Alex Moseley | Wichita B-52s | D | | All-MASL 3rd Team |
|
| | Chris Toth | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Lucas Totti | Oxford City FC of Texas | F | | Nick Perera | San Diego Sockers | F | | Freddy Moojen | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Enrique Tovar | Turlock Express/Las Vegas Legends | D | | Nelson Santana | Syracuse Silver Knights | D |
|
| 2015-16 | | All-MASL 1st Team |
|
| | Danny Waltman | Tacoma Stars | GK | | Kraig Chiles | San Diego Sockers | F | | Franck Tayou | Sonora Soles | F | | Vahid Assadpour | Missouri Comets | M | | Damian Garcia | Sonora Soles | D | | Eric Guzman | Las Vegas Legends | D | | All-MASL 2nd Team |
|
| | William Vanzela | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Leo Gibson | Missouri Comets | F | | Mauricio Salles | Ontario Fury | F | | Ian Bennett | Milwaukee Wave | M | | Victor Baez | Saltillo Rancho Seco | D | | Pat Healey | Baltimore Blast | D | | All-MASL 3rd Team |
|
| | Boris Pardo | Missouri Comets | GK | | Efrain Martinez | Chicago Mustangs | F | | Moises Gonzalez | Brownsville Barracudas | F | | Max Ferdinand | Milwaukee Wave | M | | Luis Ortega | Chicago Mustangs | D | | John Sosa | Missouri Comets | D |
|
| 2016-17 | | All-MASL 1st Team |
|
| | Chris Toth | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Max Ferdinand | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Franck Tayou | Sonora Soles | F | | Ian Bennett | Milwaukee Wave | M | | John Sosa | Kansas City Comets | D | | Stephen Basso | Harrisburg Heat | D | | All-MASL 2nd Team |
|
| | William Vanzela | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Kraig Chiles | San Diego Sockers | F | | Christian Gutierrez | Atletico Baja | F | | Taylor Bond | Chicago Mustangs | F | | Damian Garcia | Sonora Soles | F | | Chris Mattingly | St. Louis Ambush | D | | All-MASL 3rd Team |
|
| | Stephen Paterson | Kansas City Comets | GK | | Kenardo Forbes | Syracuse Silver Knights | F | | Leonardo De Oliveiro | Ontario Fury | F | | Vahid Assadpour | Kansas City Comets | M | | Ernesto Luna | Atletico Baja | D | | Victor Quiroz | San Diego Sockers | D |
|
| 2017-18 | | All-MASL 1st Team |
|
| | Chris Toth | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Max Ferdinand | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Franck Tayou | Sonora Soles | F | | Ian Bennett | Milwaukee Wave | M | | Pat Healey | Baltimore Blast | D | | Robert Acosta | St. Louis Ambush | D | | All-MASL 2nd Team |
|
| | Josh Lemos | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Kraig Chiles | San Diego Sockers | F | | Joey Tavernese | Syracuse Silver Knights | F | | Tony Donatelli | Baltimore Blast | M | | Damian Garcia | Monterrey Flash | D | | John Sosa | San Diego Sockers | D | | All-MASL 3rd Team |
|
| | Boris Pardo | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Leo Gibson | Kansas City Comets | F | | Gordy Gurson | Cedar Rapids Rampage | M | | Christian Gutierrez | Atletio Baja | M | | Adriano Dos Santos | Baltimore Blast | D | | Darren Toby | Syracuse Silver Knights | D |
|
| 2018-19 | | All-MASL 1st Team |
|
| | Boris Pardo | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Nick Perera | Tacoma Stars | F | | Max Ferdinand | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Brandon Escoto | San Diego Sockers | M | | Adriano Dos Santos | Baltimore Blast | D | | Darren Toby | Utica City FC | D | | All-MASL 2nd Team |
|
| | Josh Lemos | Milwaukee Wave | GK | | Franck Tayou | Monterrey Flash | F | | Ian Bennett | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Jonatas Melo | Baltimore Blast | M | | Marcio Leite | Milwaukee Wave | D | | Cesar Cerda | San Diego Sockers | D | | All-MASL 3rd Team |
|
| | William Vanzela | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Leo Gibson | Kansas City Comets | F | | Slavisa Ubiparipovic | Utica City FC | F | | Tony Donatelli | Baltimore Blast | M | | James Togbah | Kansas City Comets | D | | Guerrero Pino | San Diego Sockers | D |
|
| 2019-20 | | All-MASL 1st Team |
|
| | Chris Toth | Ontario Fury | GK | | Franck Tayou | Ontario Fury | F | | Ian Bennett | Milwaukee Wave | M | | Cristhian Segura | Utica City FC | M | | Drew Ruggles | Florida Tropics | D | | Marcio Leite | Milwaukee Wave | D | | All-MASL 2nd Team |
|
| | Hugo Silva | Florida Tropics | GK | | Brayan Aguilar | Monterrey Flash | F | | Max Ferdinand | Milwaukee Wave | F | | Victor Parreiras | Florida Tropics | M | | Jake Schindler | Utica City FC | D | | Onua Obasi | Utica City FC | D | | All-MASL 3rd Team |
|
| | Andrew Coughlin | Utica City FC | GK | | Leo Gibson | Kansas City Comets | F | | Ricardo Carvalho | Florida Tropics | F | | Micheal Ramos | Tacoma Stars | M | | Darren Toby | Utica City FC | D | | Elton De Oliveira | Harrisburg Heat | D |
|
| 2020-21 | | All-MASL 1st Team |
|
| | Claysson De Lima | Ontario Fury | GK | | Ian Bennett | Florida Tropics | F | | Franck Tayou | Ontario Fury | F | | Justin Stinson | Ontario Fury | M | | Cesar Cerda | San Diego Sockers | D | | Robert Palmer | Ontario Fury | D | | All-MASL 2nd Team |
|
| | Hugo Silva | Florida Tropics | GK | | Felipe De Sousa | Dallas Sidekicks | F | | Leo Gibson | Kansas City Comets | F | | Juan Carlos Gonzalez | Ontario Fury | M | | John Sosa | Kansas City Comets | D | | Ray Lee | Kansas City Comets | D | | All-MASL 3rd Team |
|
| | Paulo Nascimento | St. Louis Ambush | GK | | Nick Perera | Tacoma Stars | F | | Max Ferdinand | St. Louis Ambush | F | | Maicon De Abreu | Ontario Fury | M | | Chad Vandegriffe | Florida Tropics | D | | Stefan Mijatovic | Florida Tropics | D |
|
| 2021-22 | | All-MASL 1st Team |
|
| | Boris Pardo | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Tavoy Morgan | San Diego Sockers | F | | Victor Parreiras | Florida Tropics | F | | Ian Bennett | Milwaukee Wave | M | | Robert Palmer | Ontario Fury | D | | Chad Vandegriffe | Florida Tropics | D | | All-MASL 2nd Team |
|
| | Juan Gamboa | Dallas Sidekicks | GK | | Leo Gibson | Kansas City Comets | F | | Franck Tayou | Ontario Fury | F | | Nick Perera | Tacoma Stars | F | | Marcio Leite | Milwaukee Wave | D | | Mike Jones | Dallas Sidekicks | D |
|
| 2022-23 | | All-MASL 1st Team |
|
| | Boris Pardo | San Diego Sockers | GK | | Nick Perera | Tacoma Stars | F | | Franck Tayou | Empire Strykers | F | | Ian Bennett | Milwaukee Wave | M | | Rafa Alves | Florida Tropics | D | | Chad Vandegriffe | Florida Tropics | D | | All-MASL 2nd Team |
|
| | William Vanzela | Baltimore Blast | GK | | Lucas Roque | Baltimore Blast | F | | Hugo Puentes | Chihuahua Savage | F | | Gordy Gurson | Utica City FC | M | | Cesar Cerda | San Diego Sockers | D | | Juan Manuel Rojo | San Diego Sockers | D |
|
| 2023-24 | | All-MASL 1st Team |
|
| | Chris Toth | Tacoma Stars | GK | | Genaro Castillo | Monterrey Flash | F | | Zach Reget | Kansas City Comets | F | | Marco Fabian | Empire Strykers | M | | Ismael Rojo | Monterrey Flash | D | | Robert Palmer | Kansas City Comets | D | | All-MASL 2nd Team |
|
| | Diego Reynoso | Chihuahua Savage | GK | | Franck Tayou | Utica City FC | F | | Tavoy Morgan | San Diego Sockers | F | | Dominic Francis | Harrisburg Heat | F | | Marcio Leite | Milwaukee Wave | D | | Uzi Tayou | Texas Outlaws | D |
|
